What are the most effective models for measuring credit risk? (2024)

In my experience, while reduced-form models offer versatility in incorporating various default triggers, their reliance on calibration and estimation methods can introduce uncertainty. To address this, enhancing transparency in the calibration process and rigorously validating model assumptions can improve accuracy and reliability. Additionally, integrating economic fundamentals into the modeling framework can help mitigate the risk of overlooking crucial drivers of default, enhancing the robustness of risk assessments. Despite these challenges, reduced-form models remain valuable tools when used judiciously in conjunction with qualitative analysis and expert judgment.

A diferencia de los modelos estructurales, los modelos de forma reducida no tratan de explicar el proceso que lleva al incumplimiento, sino que se centran en estimar directamente la probabilidad de incumplimiento a partir de datos históricos y variables macroeconómicas. Estos modelos utilizan técnicas estadísticas y econométricas para predecir la probabilidad de incumplimiento.

Translated

(edited)

In my view, while machine learning excels in complex risk analysis, its opacity and regulatory concerns remain. Utilizing explainable AI techniques and hybrid models can enhance transparency and mitigate these issues, ensuring reliable risk assessments.

Con el avance de la tecnología, los modelos de aprendizaje automático han ganado popularidad en la medición del riesgo crediticio. Estos modelos pueden analizar grandes volúmenes de datos, incluyendo variables no tradicionales, para identificar patrones y predecir la probabilidad de incumplimiento. Algoritmos como árboles de decisión, redes neuronales y máquinas de vector soporte son comúnmente utilizados.

Translated

The biggest issue with machine learning is that it can not factor into black swan situations. Therefore humans intervention is required during economic crisis or other extreme circ*mstances like the COVID-19 pandemic.

(edited)

La gestion du risque de credit est complexe, et se retrouve indéniablement entre la "finance" et le "commerce" ...C'est pourquoi, le suivi de ces risques nécessite des outils (assurance-crédit, information financière, grille de score, monitoring,...), de la ressource (credit manager, compta client), mais également la mise en place d'un "comité d'engagement" qui devra statuer en dernier ressort entre le commerce et la finance sur un montant de risques acceptables...L'IA pourra aider à synthétiser & préconiser, mais la décision finale restera nécessairement humaine...

Translated

Hybrid models and a underwriter with a steady hand and experience. All the machine learning, algorithms, and jump tables mean little if they cannot assess risk beyond what they have been programmed to look for.

Sometimes using just statistical models and numbers without factoring in qualitative factors or industry expert judgements may result in inaccurate results which are not intuitive to the actual scenarios due to incomplete assessment (lacking of all parameters). Secondly, Secondly, data might not always be sufficient with respect to time frame or might lack some important scenarios and their performance on the portfolio. Such instance make it absolutely necessary to complement statistics with expert judgements and views

Agree Models will work when you have a structured product where you are lending to a uniform hom*ogeneous class & location - age, sex & other similar demographics. The Probability of default or Loss given default can all be arrived at based accuracy of timely data tested. HOWEVER what would you do in a scenario of wholesale lending where no 2 borrower characteristics are same. IN such cases we need to stick to the age old principles of his financial analysis, security evaluation, assessment of personal integrity, viability of business plan based on product superiority, marketing excellence, strong delivery & service backing an efficient working capital management system. Monitor Early Warning signals for prompt course corrections as key.

Some of the most effective models for measuring credit risk include:1. Credit Scoring Models2. Probability of Default (PD) Models3. Loss Given Default (LGD)4. Exposure at Default (EAD) Models5.Credit Portfolio Models6.Stress Testing Models: These models evaluate how a portfolio would perform under adverse economic scenarios, helping lenders assess potential losses under different conditions and improve risk management practices.The effectiveness of these models depends on various factors, including the quality of data, the accuracy of assumptions, and the relevance of the model to the specific lending context.

(edited)

From my experiences, would like to add the importance of incorporating qualitative factors into credit risk assessment. For instance, considering industry trends, management quality, and competitive positioning alongside quantitative metrics can provide a more holistic view of creditworthiness.For example, a lender evaluating a small business loan application may analyze financial statements for revenue growth and debt levels (quantitative factors), but also consider the business's reputation in the community, customer testimonials, and the owner's industry experience (qualitative factors) to assess overall credit risk accurately.