In the photo to the right, the goat kid on the left is polled while the one on the right is horned. When they’re babies, it’s not always easy to tell which are polled and which are horned (see How To Tell Whether Baby Goats Are Horned or Polled)
Most goats in the US today are naturally born with horns, and many dairy goat owners choose to de-horn (typically by disbudding) them when they’re babies for various reasons (seeDisbudding Goats). Since disbudding baby goats isnota process that anyone enjoys, I decided to pursue breeding polled goats and wondered why more breeders weren’t also.
I learned that there were once many polled goats in the US (some show scorecards even awarded more points for being polled), but that in the mid-1940s an article was published by the USDA that linked polled goats with increased chances for producing hermaphrodism (an animal with both male and female reproductive organs that’s sterile).
Polled Bramblestone Almond Joy
This was only one report and the statistical significance is still being questioned; however, breeders quickly began culling or hiding any polled genetics. According to the report, when breeding a polled goat to another polled goat, there could be a 1 in 8 chance of producing a sterile animal. So, some animals that were naturally polled were not registered as being polled, and polled animals were disbudded to disguise the fact that they were naturally hornless.
Despite the negative stigma that was attached to polled goats, there have been a few breeders over the years that have been breeding polled goats successfully without producing any increased incidence of hermaphrodism. They maintain that it’s just as likely to produce hermaphrodism when breeding two horned goats as when breeding two polled goats. There is still a great debate on the subject, so it’s important to at least understand how it’s determined whether a goat is born polled or horned.
In goat DNA, there are two “slots” for horn genes and each goat gets one slot filled by its dam and one slot filled by its sire. The horned gene is recessive and the polled gene is dominant. So, if a goat receives two horned genes it is hom*ozygous horned (and appears horned), if it receives one of each it is heterozygous polled (the dominant polled gene “hides” the horned gene and it appears hornless), and if it receives two polled genes it is hom*ozygous polled (and appears polled).
Disbudded Bramblestone Toffee
Thinking about it another way (P=polled gene, h=horned gene):
hh = hom*ozygous horned – cannot produce polled offspring unless bred to polled mate.
Ph = Heterozygous polled – can produce polled and horned offspring, unless bred to hom*ozygous polled mate.
PP = hom*ozygous polled – cannot produce horned offspring, regardless of mate.
Some breeders believe they minimize the possibility of producing a sterile animal by never breeding a polled goat to a polled goat, whereas others don’t worry about the possibility and believe the rate of incidence is the same whether breeding polled to polled, polled to horned, or horned to horned.
We prefer not having to disbud the kids, and so have quite a few polled goats. Finding a hom*ozygous polled sire would be great for us, we could breed him to horned dams and never have to disbud another kid!
